QUOTE(Ghostdraconi @ Feb 1st 2005, 5:20 AM)
I really hated the new commander at first, but he grew on me as the episode progressed. The stuff with the Genii seemed plausible to me so that didn't bother me.
Overall this was the best episode of Atlantis yet and one of the better Stargate eps in general. The only thing that bugged me is that they didn't bring more stuff from earth. With a couple more Mark II generators they probably could have gotten the sheild running.
Oh and the reason none of this is mentioned in SG1 is prpbably because the Atlantis shows are running ahead of SG1.
That's a relative term, We dont know what is a lot, and what is not. Maybe there isn't anymore, maybe they sent all. Remember, SGC is not consumerist. They dont have a factory that builds MarkII naq gens. Maybe it was only sam that built em. Who knows. the fact that they brought them is good enuff. There is never enough for power to come. It's a matter of how many naq gens are available. I agree they should have sent more ppl. I agree that they should have sent more weapons. They also stated that "we will defend atlantis at all COST" that's what triggered my doubt. If that was the case, they would have sent 2x as many ppl as the original crew were sent, it was as if, only 50 ppl were sent. [and too many guns were fired upon] In the whole ep, we saw about.. 2 groups firing, and on the big scale. we saw about 12~. That is the only unrealistic thing i can think of. Wait, there's more, when they search for wraiths inside the city, they were only in groups of 2 if not 4! Which is... uh, dumb? there were many instances where it was 4v1 and they still cant beat a wraith, with guns that is. Btw. how come, they didn't use that gun to stun the wraith? Atleast 1 guy should have used it. so they can stun, and just keep shooting. Also, the wraiths died pretty quickly by mere shooting them 5-10x. LOL. other episodes, they have to blow them up, and they are still alive
120 - The Siege (Part Two)
Jan 27th 2005, 12:46 AM
